THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Rockaway, NJ - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated July 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“We found Hancook on the way home from Newwark to Syracuse while we were dying for some comfort food. Absolutely not prepared for how delicious our meals were. The KBBQ Spicy pork hit the spot so incredibly hard.Great for a quick bite or takeout, definitely worth a stop!”

Customers` Favorites

“Missy's Main Street Cafe is a popular restaurant known for its delicious and amazing food. The menu features dishes like the Hoya Georgie wrap and sourdough toast, which are highly recommended. The small, unique atmosphere is enhanced by rustic colors and artwork, as well as a bar area. The staff is friendly and has great personalities. Despite the limited parking and often crowded space, customers find it worth the wait for the delicious food and enjoyable experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“M&S II Pizza offers a variety of delicious pizzas like BBQ chicken and meat lovers. The cheese and dough have decent flavor, and the service is quick and friendly. With no delivery option, it's best to pick up your order. The place has been around for a long time, offering welcoming service and reasonable prices. A must-visit spot for pizza lovers.”

Customers` Favorites

“Great food and great service! Came here for dinner and everything from the appetizer entree to dessert was delicious and flavorful. We will certainly be back to try other dishes. Service was outstanding:)”

Customers` Favorites

“Anthony's Pizzeria & Family Restaurant is a welcoming place with delicious food and excellent service. The owner, Anthony, is very sweet and helpful when it comes to planning orders. Their pizzas are just as good as NYC pizzas, and the portions are generous. The minestrone soup is fantastic and perfect for a chilly day, while the Stromboli with a side of sweet tomato sauce is delicious. The baked ziti with ricotta and sausage is massive and flavorful, perfect for taking leftovers home. The atmosphere is welcoming and the staff is friendly and prompt. Definitely worth a visit to try their cracker pizza!”

Customers` Favorites

“Charley's Cheesesteak is a popular spot known for its great customer service and delicious food. The staff is friendly and accommodating, willing to make adjustments to orders and offering complimentary treats. The cheesesteak is a standout dish, with perfectly cooked meat, melted cheese, and fresh bread. The flavors are well-balanced and the overall quality of the food is impressive. The owner, John, goes above and beyond to ensure a positive dining experience, making customers feel welcome and valued. With great food and remarkable service, Charley's Cheesesteak is an ideal choice for cheesesteak enthusiasts.”

Customers` Favorites

“Caffè NaVona is a restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience, ideal for both business dinners and casual visits. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with a wonderful ambiance and great music. The restaurant is spacious, featuring multiple dining rooms, a bar, and a beautiful outdoor area.Marco, the owner, greets guests with hospitality, making them feel at home. The menu is extensive, featuring a variety of Italian dishes. Complimentary bread and bruschetta are served upon seating. Standout dishes include the burrata, orchiette, jumbo shrimp pasta, and gnocchi with vodka sauce. The wine selection and co*cktails are noteworthy, and the staff is attentive and super nice.The food is excellent, and the overall experience is highly positive. Diners can enjoy a cozy indoor setting or look forward to the outdoor patio in warmer weather. There are no negative points to mention about Caffè NaVona.”

Customers` Favorites

“Tavern On the Rocks is a lively dive bar with amazing food and drinks. Enjoy happy hour deals from Wednesday to Friday, featuring $3 domestics and live music on the weekends. The kitchen is run by a talented chef with red hair, serving up delicious burgers, including the popular Rueben and hangover burger. With trivia and bingo during the week, this spot has something for everyone.”

Customers` Favorites

“Arico's Riverside Shop is a cozy breakfast joint serving great food with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff is nice and provides fantastic service. It's a great spot for families, offering games and activities for kids. A perfect spot for breakfast, lunch, or afternoon coffee.”

Customers` Favorites

“Tango Latin Asian Fusion is a highly recommended restaurant with delicious food and friendly service. The pollo enchilada and mofongo are particularly tasty. The staff is welcoming, patient, and generous with portions. Customers appreciate the unique fusion dishes and plan to return for more flavorful experiences.”

Customers` Favorites

“Pop's Place offers a casual, kid-friendly atmosphere with good food and excellent accessibility. The menu may not be immediately clear, but the dishes, such as the chopped cheese and breakfast club, are fresh and delicious. The owners are friendly, and the restaurant hosts regular events, making it a must-visit destination.”

Customers` Favorites

“Thai Nam Phet is a highly-recommended restaurant serving authentic Thai cuisine. The restaurant offers a range of options, including Thai iced tea, which is praised for its flavor. The dishes are spicy and authentic, with vegetarian options available by substituting tofu or veggies. Must-try dishes include tom yum soup, chicken pad thai, and fried rice.”

Customers` Favorites

“Alev Mediterranean Grill is a fantastic gem with amazing food and friendly service. The warm and kind employees welcome you from the moment you arrive. The Combo platter offers a taste of everything, from fresh and homemade dishes like Lebni, Stuffed Grape Leaves, and Hummus, to favorites like Chicken Kebab and Homemade Gyro. The ambience is cute, with great service and dishes like Zucchini pancakes, falafel platter, and juicy Chicken Adana kebab. Great for vegans and those with gluten restrictions.”

Customers` Favorites

“Cafelombia serves delicious food, including empanadas and bandeja paisa, in a clean and welcoming environment. The staff provides good customer service, and the restaurant is kid-friendly. With a variety of options, from snacks to full meals, Cafelombia is a great choice for a quick and satisfying meal. Despite being located in a mall food court, the restaurant maintains a clean and pleasant atmosphere.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Mill Lane Tavern Inc. offers a welcoming and chill atmosphere, where all are welcome and get along. The Bridget's smash burger with side salad is highly praised, and the bar is described as the closest thing to a Key West bar experience in North Jersey. The pub menu is available until 10 pm, making it a good local spot for a casual drink and bite.”

Customers` Favorites

“Crumbl offers a rotating selection of unique and delicious cookie flavors, with a perfect bite-sized option in their minis. The parking lot is spacious, making it convenient for customers. Customers are often pleased with the larger-than-expected cookie size and the ability to satisfy their cravings.”

Customers` Favorites

“Gelato Envy offers handmade artisan gelato that is smooth, creamy, and rich in flavor, made from real ingredients with less sugar and fewer calories than regular ice cream. The ever-changing seasonal flavors are always a hit, and the friendly staff make it a must-visit for gelato enthusiasts.”

Customers` Favorites

“Below Zero Degrees Ice Cream Rolls is a beloved spot for foodies and families alike. This shop serves phenomenal, made-from-scratch ice cream and boba, with super friendly staff providing quick and attentive service. With a cozy atmosphere and parking available, it's a perfect spot to visit anytime with family and friends.”

Customers` Favorites

“Delikositas Rockaway is a restaurant that offers a variety of food options, from classic empanadas with a unique yellow shell to a hearty and delicious Bendeja Paisa. The bagels are a highlight, known for being big, chewy, and crispy. Prices are reasonable, and the coffee has a pleasant aroma. The pastries, such as the chocolate cake and blackberry mousse, are also worth trying. The staff is friendly and polite, making it a pleasant dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Sandwiches Unlimited Lunch Box is an excellent sandwich sub shop that offers a wide variety of fresh and delicious options. The service is always friendly, and the employees are praised for their exceptional customer service. The menu features high-quality cold cuts and specialty items like the Tuscany eggplant parm and the Proud Caesar, a popular chicken Caesar wrap. Customers appreciate the generous toppings and condiments, as well as the unique flavors and textures of the sandwiches. While the dining space may be limited, the restaurant offers catering services for larger parties. Overall, Sandwiches Unlimited Lunch Box is a highly recommended business that delivers a satisfying and enjoyable dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Hibernia Inn is a family-owned restaurant that has been consistently serving excellent Italian food for many years. The menu features dishes that are fresh, full of flavor, and expertly prepared. Standout options include the potato crusted grouper, a chicken dish with pasta, and tender pork chops. The restaurant offers a quiet atmosphere, great co*cktails, and a full bar, including the recommended Robert Mondovi Cab. The professional staff provides excellent service, making it a must-visit destination for a fantastic dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“P.F. Chang's offers a delightful dining experience with exceptional service. Upon arrival, guests are warmly greeted and made to feel at home. The staff, including servers like Ty and Yajaira, provide attentive and personalized service, offering great recommendations. The food is a highlight, with dishes such as the Changs spicy chicken, Mongolian beef, and chicken lettuce wraps bursting with flavor and beautifully presented. The restaurant's welcoming atmosphere and impeccable service are complemented by the bar, where bartenders like Lizzie can create delicious custom co*cktails. Manager Yasmine ensures a high standard of hospitality. Dining at P.F. Chang's promises a memorable and enjoyable meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Exchange is a local favorite, serving delicious food and drinks with great service. The restaurant offers a lively atmosphere on Tuesday nights, with karaoke and a good selection of drinks. While the menu may not display prices, the staff is friendly and responsive, and the wait is prompt. The menu features popular dishes like shrimp tacos, which are well-received by customers.”

Customers` Favorites

“RJ's Pizzeria serves delicious food that has earned a great reputation in the area. Their cheesesteaks are a hit, and their pizzas are made with exceptional sauce, cheese, crust, and toppings. The selection of pizzas is great, with one style reminiscent of homemade Italian pizza. Salads are also a highlight, with the caprese salad being a popular choice. The staff is welcoming and focused, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. With consistently high-quality food, RJ's Pizzeria is a top spot for a satisfying meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Hibernia Diner is a welcoming and accommodating restaurant, known for its delicious food, friendly service, and clean, comfortable environment. The staff is attentive, especially to children and those with dietary restrictions. Customers highly recommend the Hibernia Diner for a great dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Tony's Famous Pizzeria is a charming spot in a lake community with amazing pizza and top-notch vodka sauce. Their gluten-free pizza is the best ever, with a thick crust and real cheese. The wings are also a hit, perfect for the kids. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this hidden gem is worth a visit for delicious food and friendly service.”

Customers` Favorites

“3 Hermanos Mexican Restaurant is a family-owned eatery serving authentic Mexican cuisine. The food is prepared fresh and tastes like a home-cooked meal. The menu features a variety of dishes, including the popular birria, which is a favorite among customers. The portions are generous and reasonably priced. The agua frescas are also a highlight, with flavors like strawberry and fresh ingredients. The restaurant is kid-friendly, with a welcoming atmosphere and a family-owned environment. With its delicious food, reasonable prices, and friendly service, 3 Hermanos Mexican Restaurant is a must-visit destination for those craving authentic Mexican cuisine.”

Customers` Favorites

“Domenico's Pizza is a popular spot, known for their quick delivery service, even during busy hours. They prioritize their regular customers, going out of their way to accommodate their needs. Their pizzas are fantastic, with options available for those with dietary restrictions, such as gluten-free pizza at a reasonable price. The menu is varied, and they are accommodating to special requests. The pizzeria serves a classic NY-style pizza, which is a highlight for many customers. While the atmosphere may vary depending on the location, the pizza is always a winner.”

“Llama Ice Cream offers a variety of unique flavors like Lucuma, Passion Fruit, mamey, Peruvian lacuma, coffee, coconut, cookies & cream, and more. The serving staff is friendly and helpful, although it can get busy with long lines. Some customers experienced minor issues like ice crystals in the ice cream. Despite some setbacks with coupons and discounts, the overall experience was positive, with tasty treats making up for any inconveniences. The location may be a bit tricky to find due to outdated maps, but the delicious ice cream makes it worth the search.”

Customers` Favorites

“don't expect great cell service in this place.”

“Gyro King serves great food at an affordable price with generous servings of rice, veggies, and meat. The lamb is soft and juicy, and the staff is super friendly. The restaurant offers a clean and flavorful experience, with a good amount of meat and just the right level of heat. Popular dishes include the lamb bowl, perfectly balanced with rice and salad, and the popcorn chicken, which is fresh and delicious. Overall, Gyro King is a highly recommended spot for halal food in Parsippany/Dover.”

Customers` Favorites

“Bagel Nosh/Delicias Catrachas is a cozy spot for Honduran cuisine. The menu is diverse, and everything is made to order, ensuring freshness. The staff is friendly and helpful, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The decor and music add to the inviting ambiance. The food is fantastic, with options like pupusas and breakfast sandwiches. Prices are reasonable, and a variety of drinks are available. Reviewers highly recommend Bagel Nosh for a great bagel experience, with high-quality food and a cozy atmosphere.”

“Green Pond Deli serves freshly prepared meats, including Roast Beef, Pastrami, and Corned Beef, and offers generous portions. Their homemade side salads and soups are also excellent. The deli's sandwiches, such as the Italian Sub and Reuben, are made with fresh ingredients and are highly recommended. Friendly staff and great value make it a favorite spot.”

“Adam's Beer Garden offers an exciting outdoor experience with a fun and lively atmosphere. The venue features a pool table, darts, and excellent live music, creating an enjoyable setting for guests. The establishment has an ample outdoor space, allowing visitors to spread out and fully immerse themselves in the vibrant ambiance. With a wide selection of beers on tap and reasonably priced cigars, Adam's Beer Garden provides a great destination for those seeking a casual and entertaining night out.”

Customers` Favorites

“Brick 46 is a reliable spot for delicious food that never disappoints. This family-friendly restaurant has hosted successful events, including children's birthday parties, with attentive hosts and seamless execution. Their catering services offer many vegetarian options, including stuffed shells and cavatelli, and provide hot, ready-to-serve meals that impress guests. With great food and excellent service, Brick 46 is a top choice for any occasion.”

Customers` Favorites

“Gio's Artisan Pizza is a hidden gem serving the best pizza in the area. Their pizzas, including vegetarian options with Brussels sprouts, are consistently delicious. Fresh and tasty salads are also available, with quick service and plenty of seating. This highly-recommended spot has earned a loyal following, with customers raving about the great taste and quality of their pizzas.”

Customers` Favorites

“Starseed Bakery offers a variety of gluten-free and sugar-free treats that are both delicious and guilt-free. With options like lemon strawberry cupcakes, mixed berry coffee cake, and brookies, the bakery caters to different dietary restrictions without compromising on taste. The owner's knowledge and the well-labeled ingredients make it easy for customers to find suitable items. While the store is small and mainly for takeout or shipping, the quality of the treats is worth it. From unicorn-themed cupcakes to healthier sweeteners, Starseed Bakery focuses on using organic ingredients and avoiding additives, preservatives, and chemicals. Whether you have specific dietary needs or just want a tasty treat, Starseed Bakery is a must-try for anyone looking for unique and flavorful desserts.”

“Muldoon's offers a beautiful Irish pub atmosphere with delicious food and excellent service. The wings and chicken parm come highly recommended, while the steak tacos are loved by kids. The homemade high-quality cooking and friendly staff make dining here a pleasant experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Red Hut Diner is a cozy and friendly restaurant with an "old school diner" vibe. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a comfortable seating area. The menu offers a variety of options, including the DX cheeseburger, protein omelette, and chicken gyro with fries. Prices are fair, with a total bill of around $52 for three people. The waitstaff is friendly and attentive, and the kitchen can accommodate guests with food sensitivities or allergies.”

Customers` Favorites

“Great sandwiches and great prices.......I eat there 3 times a week and love the daily specials.......friendly staff”

“Everything we have ever bought has been delicious!”

“Rockaway Auntie Anne’s team helped cater my work event and it came out amazing! Their attention to detail and hospitality, going above and beyond made the day that much better! Will definitely order again for future events!”

Customers` Favorites

“Nori Sushi is a reliable choice in the food court, offering fresh and delicious ingredients at an unbeatable price. Despite a past incident, the restaurant consistently provides great service and handmade sushi made to order. Their spicy mayo is a highlight, making it a healthier and more satisfying option compared to others in the food court.”

Customers` Favorites

“Pizza Rustica, located in a strip mall off Main Street in Rockaway, is a warm and welcoming restaurant that serves delicious pizzas. The atmosphere is cozy, with a large dining room and plenty of seating. The menu offers a wide selection of pies, including unique combinations like broccoli rabe with sausage. The crust is described as having a great crunch and chew, while the sauce is fresh and flavorful. The cheese is generous and well-balanced, and the pesto adds an extra layer of flavor. The staff is friendly and attentive, making the dining experience enjoyable. Overall, Pizza Rustica is a must-visit for pizza lovers, with its excellent selection of pies and warm atmosphere.”

Customers` Favorites

“Five Guys is a popular fast-casual dining spot that serves consistently delicious burgers and fries. The restaurant offers a simple yet mouthwatering menu with customizable options to cater to every craving. The quality of ingredients shines through in every bite, from the juicy handcrafted burgers to the perfectly seasoned fries. Friendly and efficient staff manage the inflow of orders, ensuring a smooth dining experience. The restaurant is also known for its cleanliness and generous portions, with extra fries being a common occurrence. With its great food and convenient location, Five Guys is a top choice for burger lovers and families alike.”

Customers` Favorites

“Super Chix - Rockaway, NJ is a popular restaurant that has received positive reviews from customers. The Nashville hot breaded chicken is a standout dish, with customers raving about its flavor and moisture. The restaurant also offers a salad topped with the Nashville chicken, which is a hit with diners. Additionally, the mint Oreo custard is a delightful dessert option. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, with lowered side walk access, though it lacks automatic doors. Customers have noted that the chicken is fresh and never frozen, and the overall dining experience is excellent. Super Chix is a small national chain that has become a favorite among locals and travelers alike.”

Customers` Favorites

“Riviera Maya Mexican Restaurant is a family-run establishment known for its charming ambiance and fast, friendly service. The restaurant offers a variety of Mexican dishes with muted to good flavors, including fresh salsa and chips. One highlight is the live guacamole preparation at the table, providing a fresh and customizable start to the meal. The tacos are a standout, filled with perfectly seasoned ingredients. However, some visitors have found the cost of chips and salsa to be high, with three small bags of chips and salsa costing $27. Nonetheless, the restaurant is a must-visit for Mexican cuisine enthusiasts seeking a memorable experience with authentic food and a touch of mystery.”

“I had a really great experience. They were cleaning up and the gentleman with curly hair and glasses I wasn’t able to catch his name went out of his way to make me a milkshake. I really appreciated the above and beyond service and I hope that the managers that see this will compensate him for his efforts.Thanks again !!”

Customers` Favorites

“Dunkin' on this unnamed location offers excellentene service, quick order completion, and a friendly atmosphere. Coffee is highly regarded for its freshness and taste. The seating area is clean and spacious. Parking is plentiful. This Dunkin' is a great choice for a satisfying breakfast or a quick snack.”

Customers` Favorites

“Lola's Tex Mex offers a varied menu, with standout dishes like the delectable birria tacos and fantastic steak tacos. While the prices may be on the higher end, especially for a food court setting, the quality of the food is undeniable. The restaurant's staff provide a pleasant dining experience, and the waterfront location is praised by long-time customers. Although one reviewer encountered some issues with the carne fries and rice and beans, the overall consensus is that Lola's Tex Mex is a superb establishment worth visiting.”

Customers` Favorites

“PrimoHoagies offers good food, quick service, and a helpful, motivated staff. The restaurant has moderate pricing, a clean environment, and ample parking. Customers can also find Tesla superchargers nearby. The staff provides great customer interaction, and the food, including Italian and cheesesteak options, is incredible.”

Customers` Favorites

“No.1 Chinese Restaurant is a popular spot for delicious Chinese food and excellent customer service. The staff is kind and friendly, with prompt phone service and timely food preparation. The menu offers a range of options, including highlights like Pork Fried Rice with hunks of pork and General Taos. The restaurant is also very kid-friendly. While some customers have noticed smaller portions with less meat and more veggies, the food is generally good and satisfying. Favorites include Chicken Chow Mein and Boneless Spareribs. With fast service and reasonable prices, No.1 Chinese Restaurant is a top choice for Chinese takeout in the area.”

Customers` Favorites

“China Garden of Rockaway offers delicious Chinese cuisine, with dishes like General Tsos, crab ragoons, and pan-fried dumplings receiving high praise. The restaurant is known for prompt delivery, ensuring hot and fresh food reaches customers' doors. Customers appreciate the authentic flavors in dishes like beef and broccoli or vegetable lo mein. While some experienced issues with delivery services like Grub Hub, the taste and quality of the food make China Garden a top choice for Chinese takeout in New Jersey.”

Customers` Favorites

“East Cafe is a Chinese and sushi restaurant that offers a cozy indoor seating and good service. The restaurant is conveniently located near a local hotel and shops. The food is flavorful, with a variety of options for appetizers such as fried dumplings and beef on a stick. The General Tso's lunch combo and tangerine beef are popular dishes, known for their sweet and spicy taste. In addition to Chinese food, the restaurant also has a sushi bar with quality sushi options. Overall, East Cafe stands out for its tasty and flavorful food in a pleasant environment.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Olive Garden Italian Restaurant offers a pleasant dining experience with an excellent ambiance and attentive servers. Customers can enjoy a variety of Italian dishes, including Alfredo pasta with shrimp, as well as a kid-friendly menu. The restaurant also provides ample parking for its customers.”

Customers` Favorites

“Arby's is a favorite spot for many, offering delicious options like the French Dip, smokehouse brisket, and beef & cheddar sandwiches. The restaurant is kid-friendly with kids meals available and is wheelchair accessible on the first floor. Despite the distance for some customers, the friendly service, cleanliness, and variety on the menu make it a standout choice. This Arby's location in New Jersey is a great alternative to the usual fast-food spots in the area, offering a unique experience and, of course, the famous meats.”

Customers` Favorites

“Miller's Ale House is a great spot for a bite to eat. The food is fantastic, with options like the Brunch Burger and Bavarian pretzel appetizer. The portions are adequate and prices are fair. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is suitable for families and groups of friends. Vegetarian options are plentiful, and dietary restrictions can be accommodated. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, with no stairs and accessible tables. While some dishes, like the wings, may be overpriced, the overall experience is enjoyable, making it a great meet-up spot.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Rockaway Barn Restaurant is a popular spot, known for its lively atmosphere and varied drink options at the bar. The restaurant can get busy, but the wait time for a table is reasonable, and customers can enjoy a basket of bread while waiting for their food. The menu offers tasty options such as spinach artichoke dip, fries, and mac and cheese. Some dishes, like the mac and cheese, might be a bit dry, but overall, the food is highly praised. The service is a standout feature, with attentive and friendly staff, including waitress Denise and manager Garrison, who ensure a great dining experience. However, there has been a complaint about a $2 charge for ice in a drink, which some customers might find surprising.”